Start with what each quote actually covers
Two quotes can use the same artwork and list the same width while describing different signs. One supplier might quote for the name in a single colour. Another might include an illuminated emblem, a second colour and a different acrylic backboard. Before comparing totals, put the two specifications and their proofs side by side and mark every difference.
Check what the quoted width measures. It could be the illuminated artwork or the outside edge of the backboard. Ask for the overall width and height, including the acrylic, and the width of the main lettering if that matters to you. A sign can be the same width on paper and take up more wall space because the artwork is stacked. If the space is tight, use the Neon Now sign size guide to plan the footprint before requesting prices.
Worked comparison of two briefs at the same width
The featured image shows two illustrative mock-ups for EMBER, a fictional café. Both briefs are for the same indoor wall and ask for the same overall width and warm white lettering. The two versions show how much can change while the quoted width stays the same.
- Brief A — lettering on clear acrylic. The word EMBER is the only illuminated element. It sits on a clear rectangular backboard.
- Brief B — lettering and flame on black acrylic. The lettering stays the same. A hot pink illuminated flame sits above it, and the rectangular backboard is taller to accommodate the emblem. The brief asks for a black finish.
If Brief B comes back higher, there are several differences to check. The flame adds another lit element and introduces a second colour. The taller outline changes the amount of backboard space the design needs. The black finish is also a different specification from clear acrylic. The example illustrates those differences without assigning a price to any of them.
Decide what matters before asking for revisions. If the pink flame is how people recognise the café, keep it in the brief and ask for the same design on clear and black acrylic. If the black panel is needed to give the lettering a clean background against a patterned wall, keep the panel and ask whether leaving out the flame changes the total. The most useful comparison keeps the feature you care about fixed while changing the one you can live without.
Change one part of the brief at a time
To compare width, ask for the same artwork, colours and finish at two widths. Request the overall height for both and check whether any details had to change at the smaller size. If a supplier removes part of the artwork to make the smaller version work, the price difference reflects a change in the design as well as a change in size.
To compare artwork, fix the overall dimensions and backboard specification first. Ask the supplier to price the design with and without the detail you are considering, such as an illuminated border or emblem. Have them mark which elements light up on each proof. If you want to compare a single colour with two colours, keep the artwork the same for that comparison.
To compare finishes, keep the artwork, dimensions and board shape the same and request two finishes. The Neon Now guide to backboard materials and shapes explains the options. Ask to see how each backboard is intended to look with the sign switched off, especially if the sign will spend part of the day unlit. That makes it easier to decide whether the finish is worth paying for in your setting.
Check what is included in the total
Once the designs match, compare the package. Check whether the quote includes delivery to your postcode, the power supply, a dimmer if you want one, and fixings for your intended mounting method. If you need someone to install the sign, ask whether fitting is included or quoted separately. Compare the total payable, check whether any applicable tax is included, and ask how long the quote is valid.
Make sure the quotes also assume the same location and deadline. A sign for an indoor wall and one for an exposed location are different briefs. Tell both suppliers exactly where the sign will go and ask them to confirm the proposed specification in writing. If the sign is for an opening or an event, give both suppliers the date you need it in hand and ask when that delivery timing can be confirmed.
Send the same brief to each supplier
Attach the same artwork and wall photo, then send one written specification. Give your maximum overall width and height, the elements that must light up, your colour and backboard choices, how the sign will be mounted, where it will be used and when you need it. Mark anything optional and ask for it as a separate price or as a second version.
For the EMBER example, the request could read like this.
Please quote for warm white EMBER lettering and a hot pink illuminated flame on a rectangular backboard for an indoor wall. Price the same design on clear and black acrylic, keeping the overall width, height and layout the same. Please show what lights up on the proof and confirm what is included in the delivered total.
If you already have two quotes, send that clarification before starting over. Ask each supplier to confirm which details their price covers and to revise only the differences you want to compare. For a quote based on your own artwork, upload your logo or design to Neon Now and include the specification you want priced.